Stewart Tunnel to be Repaired

The Friends of the Badger and Sugar River State Trails are pleased to share an update from the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources regarding the Stewart Tunnel on the Badger State Trail.
In a letter dated August 1, 2022, Steve Schmelzer, Bureau Director of the Parks and Recreation Management Program with the WI DNR, thanked all those who submitted comments on the Draft Stewart Tunnel Alternatives.
Schmelzer reports that a total of 901 public comments were received, both through the online feedback form and in writing. The comments indicated a strong preference for the Tunnel Repair Alternatives compared to the Tunnel Reroute or Removal Alternatives. In order of priority, respondents indicated that preserving tunnel access, safety, and historic preservation were the most important factors to consider.
The DNR has recommended that Alternative 4 – Corrugated Metal Pipe Lining be the method chosen to address the safety, necessary repairs and longevity of the tunnel. This alternative is recommended because it would provide a long-term solution for ensuring a safer year-round access to the tunnel for recreational purposes while also preserving the bat hibernaculum. Additionally, the anticipated construction costs are reasonable, and this option would have a long lifespan, requiring little maintenance.
Design adjustments may be necessary as the project enters the design and engineering phase to meet budget constraints, comply with historical, cultural, and endangered resources review requirements, or contend with unforeseen circumstances. Engineering assessments may also be conducted as part of the design process to explore the feasibility of exposing sections of the original tunnel done in conjunction with Alternative 4. The other Tunnel Repair Alternatives (Alternatives 2, 3 and 5) outlined in the Alternatives Analysis may be considered if Alternative 4 is not proven feasible.
The final Stewart Tunnel Alternatives Analysis report can be seen by visiting the Stewart Tunnel webpage: https://dnr.wisconsin.gov/topic/parks/badger/tunnel. The report also contains a summary of the stakeholder and public input that was received and the responses to the online feedback form.
Moving forward, the WI DNR will be recommending the funding of Alternative 4 in the 2023-2025 DNR capital budget.